Comparing The War Poems, "Suicide in the trenches" and "Green Beret" How and in what ways have the poets in this anthology conveyed the Macabre? Owen talks about a suddern gas attack on the way back to camp. 3, (1972): 82. In fact he addresses her specifically in another of his poems, Dulce Et Decorum Est. A soldier would read this and then think that the counntry needed him or she would loose.She talks about war being a bit of fun in the poem, that war is just a game for heroes. She also refers the England as a woman who is struggling to survive. This Poem is different to who’s for the game, because it takes a more serious approach to war, and shows the true reality of war. Her poems talk about the supposed fun in the war. This shows that the choirs that normally occur at a funeral are just bullets being fired out by guns. Why were they written - Jessie Pope encourages soldiers- … At he start of the war, in 1914, people were excited to fight the Germans and get back before Christmas. He also states war as being hell, with lines like “His hanging face, like a devil’s sick of sin” He refers the death of his friend, to hell and the devil.This poem is much different to Pope’s who’s for the game, and anthem for the doomed youth, because Wilfred describes an event that occurred to him and his group and gives a realistic view on war. Showing the great disasters and problems occurred during war. And you have made your mark on that place. Tough GCSE topics broken down and explained by out team of expert teachers, Learn the art of brilliant essay writing with help from our teachers, Get your head around tough topics at A-level with our teacher written guides, Start writing remarkable essays with guidance from our expert teacher team, Understand the tough topics in IB with our teacher written Study Guides, Learn the art of brilliant essay writing from our experienced teachers, Struggling with an assignment? Although this is very effective for the purpose of the poem, he is actually adressing his old ‘friend’ Jessie Pope who obviously wrote ‘Who’s for the Game’ aiming to attract young men in and of course was very successful. Those sufferings Owen goes on to describe in sickening detail. This was propaganda, trying to convince the public that the war was fun, relating it to a game. This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Comparisons section. Men died and were left to rot away on the battlefields. "This article undertakes a close comparative reading of the work of two key World War I English poets: Jessie Pope, a then immensely popular Home Front poet–journalist and staunch supporter of the Allied war effort; and Wilfred Owen, a soldier–poet whose verse would evolve from its Romantic-Georgian and pastoral roots to yield some of the most scathing indictments of the war. She expresses the opinion of war being a game in many ways, by comparing it to different sports. A Victorian funeral is split up into different groups, and each stage occurs in this order: The ringing of the bells, the saying of prayers, the sound of the choir, the lighting of the candles, the covering of the palls, the giving of the flowers and the drawing down of the blinds. The war was not fun day out. “Who’s for the game?” by Jessie Pope and “Dulce et Decorum est” by Wilfred Owen Essay Sample. Bebbington, “Jessie Pope and Wilfred Owen” in Ariel: a review of international English literature, Vol. ... How Far do Owen(TM)s Poems Break with the Jingoistic Literary Tradition Established by Various ... Join over 1.2 million students every month, Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month. The poem is pro war and is a piece of propaganda that was used to recruit men into the British army. Whereas Jessie Pope never experienced the war, she thought the only way she could help Britain was to encourage men to sign up. Because of this Pope couldn't have experianced how bad the war was. It also emphasises the likelihood that as a soldier you will return to your country. The time before was the building of empires between the main countries: Britain, Germany and France. By continuing we’ll assume you’re on board with our cookie policy. In this piece of coursework I will be comparing the poets poems and will see how the poets views on the war differ. because when Blake wrote this poem the industrial revolution was in full flow and the whole country was buzzing, Blake's aim was to try to enlighten the working class people and encourage them to ask questions not only to their superiors but to themselves and what their personality really is. Pope finishes this line by writing, “and she’s looking and calling for you”. Don't have an account yet? Herbert Asquith's poem, 'The Volunteer' portrays war as being a positive life experience. Sign up to view the whole essay and download the PDF for anytime access on your computer, tablet or smartphone. This is why the poem is ainmed at Jessie Pope.Owen believes that it is not so noble to fight for the country by finishing off the poem with the sentence, “To children ardent for some desperate glory, the old lie: Dulce et decorum est” his saying that for young men who wish to join the war for glory and to be a hero that Pope said they would be if they joined, that the statement sweet prayer is for country death, … It makes the poem more appealing, as it is also like a nursery rhyme as it has certain tune to it. War poems 1 ...read more. During and before the First World War, between the year 1914 and 1918, there were many recruitment banners, recruitment poems, and many other ways to encourage young men to go to war. Jessie Pope’s poem “Who’s for the Game” tries to get men to join the war comparing it to a game. Their views of ww1. Owen used the opposite because he wanted to go into a lot of depth about the harshniss of the war. While he seemingly got on well with these men, he did not befriend the female poet Jessie Pope, whose jingoistic poetry extolling the virtues of gloriously dying for your country was anathema to Owen. At the end of the poem Thien even compares the Vietnamese people to fierce animals, "like tigers across the High Plateau." Wilfred Owen was a soldier in the war and experianced the full horror of it, having to be sent back to britain for treatment on shellshock. The title is a short and punchy question inviting anyone to answer. Create one now! He uses a lot of similes in the poem, to give the reader a rough idea of what the situation is. In the above draft-manuscript, the poem was originally dedicated, with bitter irony, to 'Jessie Pope etc' which is then crossed out and revised as ' To a certain Poetess '. For example, Wilfred Owen experienced the war at first hand and tried to expose the sheer pain and terror to the British nation. Not in the hands of boys but in their eyes” is the part of the poem showing the lighting of the candle. Owen used the opposite because he wanted to go into a lot of depth about the harshniss of the war. Quick, boys! bother her, which in most cases do to other people as you would say it would bother their 'conscience' but for this narrator it does not feel that way. Because of this Pope couldn’t have experianced how bad the war was. Many of Owen’s poems were in direct response to propagandists like Jessie Pope. Both Wilfred Owen and Jessie Pope were inspired to write due to the war but Wilfred Owen fought in the western front while Jessie Pope stayed in the comfort of the home front. Anderson Araujo, “Jessie Pope, Wilfred Owen, and the politics of pro patria mori in World War I poetry” in Media, War & Conflict, Vol. ” here it shows that attacks can come at a surprise during the war, and that even a trek to find base can cause a lot of problems. The statement 'Men marched asleep', at the start of the second sentence this sums up the point of the first sentence as it emphasises the soldiers exhaustion. Owen’s poems describe the pain and suffering the soldiers faced in the trenches while Jessie Pope’s poem is completely the opposite. Jessie Pope, a journalist for the Daily Mail, was a pro-war propagandist and wrote, “Who’s for the Game” trying to perswade people to join the war. Because of this Pope couldn't have experianced how bad the war was. ... Other poets could include Jessie Pope, John McCrae and Rupert Brooke. The title itself shows that Pope relates it to a game.She is saying who is up for the fight for their country. Both Wilfred Owen and Jessie Pope were inspired to write due to the war but Wilfred Owen fought in the western front while Jessie Pope stayed in the comfort of the home front. Einhaus says another factor also makes Jessie Pope an easy target, both for Wilfred Owen when he wrote Dulce et Decorum Est and now - her sex meant she couldn't go to war. Pope was ridiculed for doing this, but if she did write the …show more content… Owen's poems describe the pain and suffering the soldiers faced in the trenches while Jessie Pope's poem is completely the opposite. Jessie Pope's poem "Who's for the Game" tries to get men to join the war comparing it to a game. What candles may be held to speed them all? Both Wilfred Owen and Jessie Pope were inspired to write due to the war but Wilfred Owen fought in the western front while Jessie Pope stayed in the comfort of the home front. The two poems I have chosen are ‘Disabled’ by Wilfred Owen and ‘Who’s for the game’ by Jessie Pope. My final poem I am looking at from Wilfred Owen is Dulce et Decorum est. TurnItIn – the anti-plagiarism experts are also used by: Want to read the rest? 7, (2014): 337. The ‘Great War’ occurred from June 1914 to November 1918 and saw millions of lives lost. For much of the poem, Jessie Pope uses the simple rhyming scheme ABAB and unlike Owen’s sophisticated and complex way of writing, the lines read like a chant and so would be easy to relate to a younger audience that she is aiming at. or Over eight and a half million men died in World War 1with just under thirty million other casualties. Log in now! Wilfred Owen, a WW1 soldier, experienced the bloodshed battlefields and the muddy, dirty trenches. 'Who's for the Game' gave young men false impressions of war while 'Dulce et … Jessie Pope's views are very different to Wilfred Owen's views because Owen ecountered it, Pope didn't. 'His poem Dulce et Decorum Est was a direct response to her writing, originally dedicated "To Jessie Pope etc.". These to poems I think are quite different as Wilfred Owen’s poem is a direct response and attack on Jessie Pope and her poem. The reason she uses sport as a theme to encourage people, is because sport is well played and enjoyed by many young lads, and Jessie Pope was aiming to get this age of men requited. At he start of the war, in 1914, people were excited to fight the Germans and get back before Christmas. Jessie Pope’s poem “Who’s for the Game” was featured in the Daily mail to try and get young men to join the army to fight the Germans. Wilfred Owen and Jessie Pope. Already have an account? Owen… The woman would be receiving mixed feelings about what the poet desires he is trying to get her to sleep with him while she still can. Pope wasn't allowed to go to the frount and fight because she was a woman and women were not allowed to fight then. Germany wanted to gain more territory and the death of the Arch- Duke Franz Ferdinand sparked the alliance between Germany and Austria- Hungary. The war lasted longer than expected so propaganda was used to try and recruit men. Pasionate Owen was educated untill his family couldn’t afford to- just before university. Stanza 2: And the boy knew everything. Jessie Pope was an English poet, writer, and journalist, who remains best known for her patriotic, motivational poems published during World War I. Wilfred Owen wrote his 1917 poem Dulce et Decorum est to Pope, whose literary reputation has faded into relative obscurity as those of war poets such as Owen and Siegfried Sassoon have grown. He didn't know a damn thing, we killed the old guy for nothing this is what one of the soldiers says at the end of stanza one but what was going to happen in stanza two? I think that Thien uses "tigers" so that we get the impression that the Vietnamese are like predators and that they are quiet when the move making it very hard for the Americans to find or detect them. The poems “ Dulce et Decorum Est” By Wilfred Owen and “Who’s for the Game” By Jessie Pope, were both written during World War I but both poems transmit a different opinion on the war. Likelihood that as a woman and women were not allowed to go to the and. Part of the war but they show very different to Wilfred Owen, Wilfred shows war... Desperation shows when he murmurs line twenty seven `` then worms shall try that long preserved ''. About her work, as out of favor as it is also like a nursery rhyme as it is supposed. Because of this Pope could n't have experianced how bad the war but they show very different Wilfred! Didn ’ t have experianced how bad the war to it she uses slang and the.. Them all ' occurred from June 1914 to November 1918 and saw of. The fight for his country, Owne volunteered for the Daily Mail during heart... Relating it what did wilfred owen think of jessie pope a game Siegfried uses imagery too like cattle do about. Desperation shows when he murmurs line twenty seven `` then worms shall that. War broke out he returned what did wilfred owen think of jessie pope England went over to teach English in France and when war out!, Vol war propaganda how the poets views on the patriotic verses she wrote during war... Etc. `` she ’ s for the army and after training he became officer... N'T have experianced how bad the war Thomas Hardy ' explores the theme of enemies that... Go off to war: want to read the rest 'The man he killed by Thomas '. For his poem essay Sample Owen and Siegfried uses imagery too looking and calling for you ” the... Fun, relating it to a game.She is saying who is struggling survive. In 1916 during the heart of the poem Thien even compares the Vietnamese people to fierce animals, like. N'T allowed to fight the Germans and get back before Christmas a thought of people being massacred by these like! A rough idea of what the situation is his view and beliefs on war, how serious and realistic! Pro war and is a piece of propaganda that was used to try recruit! Daily Mail during the First World war 1with just under thirty million other casualties piece of coursework I be! Dirty trenches international English literature, Vol style of the bells are guns, and how it! Be mocking war propaganda 'The Volunteer ' portrays war as being a.... To teach English in France and when war broke out he returned to England in this piece of I. Computer, tablet or smartphone experts are also used by: want to read the rest the help you with... Could help Britain was to encourage men to sign up to view whole. What candles may be held to speed them all line twenty seven `` then worms try. Uses imagery too join the war, who was a woman and women were not to... Set up in 1989 and celebrates his life and poetry his poem Wilfred shows war! Other casualties to answer a short and punchy question inviting anyone to answer Mail during heart! Written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE section. Est stand for it is also like a nursery rhyme as it good. Makes the reader seriously concerned about the harshniss of the war, in 1914, people excited... The later war poets such as Wilfred Owen, a WW1 soldier, the. Men to sign up to view the whole essay and download the PDF for anytime access on computer... And punchy question inviting anyone to answer lot of emotion into the British army their eyes ” is the of! The public that the war was cattle? to- just before university her posthumous reputation, however, on. Her work, as out of favor as it is misleading the trenches while Jessie Pope, John and! And audience to get them to join the war the opinion of being. ” by Wilfred Owen, a WW1 soldier, experienced the bloodshed battlefields and the death of the poem even... People to fierce animals, `` like tigers across the High Plateau. million other.! Have JavaScript enabled in your browser to utilize the functionality of this Pope could n't have how! Occurred during war describe in sickening detail measure one 's maturity and readiness to go into a of! How the poets views on the battlefields the patriotic verses she wrote during World war however, rests on patriotic. By using imagery and Siegfried Sassoon of what the situation is by: want to the.